Instructions to evaluators: Working as a group , provide brief comments identifying strengths and weaknesses in each of the categories listed below. Award an overall numerical score in each category and record the total below.
Technical merit
Accuracy of problem statement:
Validity and depth of analysis:
Soundness and relevance of conclusions:
Overall technical merit (award fractional score if appropriate):
5 (excellent) 4 3 (some errors or omissions) 2 1 (fatal flaws)
Communication
Organization and physical presentation:
Clarity:
Writing style, grammar, mechanics of language:
Overall communication rating (award fractional score if appropriate):
5 (excellent)
4 3 (some errors
or omissions) 2
1 (fatal flaws)
TOTAL: